Romantic Hotels in Fire Island, New York

"Property was an excellent condition, but room was a little bit on the old side. Front door. Lock was broken and bathroom door handle was jiggling needed to be tightened."

"Amazing hotel. Beautiful building, outdoor space, and location. The staff was polite and professional. "

"My favorite "

"We spent Valentine's Day weekend here and they did it up with the vibe. The colorful hue that illuninated their exteriors was great to see at night. The V-Day decor indoors helped set the mood just right. The room was cozy. And the snow the next day added to the cozy ambience. The staff was all amazing - Can't wait to come back."

"The room we had needed some repairs but since it was got only one night we just ignored it. "

"Loved it!"

"Excellent "

"Perfect"

"They put rose petals out for us! Probably because of the Valentine weekend... Every aspect of the experience has been reading good!"