Romantic Hotels in Fire Island, New York

"Great location. "

"We enjoyed our stay at Jake's 58. Room prices were very reasonable. The rooms are very comfortable and roomy enough. It was a plus to have a refrigerator in the room. Going downstairs for coffee/tea etc. was very easy and not too inconvenient. We appreciated the amount of security at the doors. Valet service makes parking less of a hassle as long as you don't mind spending $10 each time you park. We would stay again."

"Check in person,Carlos, did an excellent job. Two thumbs up."

"The best "

"Very nice area"

"Nice property. Clean and comfortable."