Hotels with Restaurants in Fire Island, New York

"Quite place to spend weekend. Love everything about this place but smoking rule is not enforced . I saw guest smoking in front of the hotel and the smoke going into the hotel lobby area and this was smelling cigarette smoke even when they said Hotel is smoke free hotel . The room I check in, was ealier occupied by a smoker and this hit me the moment I went in. Nice breakfast, nice location and family friendly."

"The hotel was nice and clean"

"Clean. Quiet. Front desk very hospitable. "

"The hotel is lovely . The rooms are spacious . This was my second stay at this hotel and I enjoyed it. Very clean inside rooms. Ice machines works great . I really like this hotel, But I lost $7 using the washer and dryer , which the front desk said they couldn’t do anything about the machines are third party. So I had to leave the hotel at midnight to find a 24 hour laundry to dry my clothing ."

"The breakfast should improvise.."

"Wonderful, close to all our needs, thank you!"

"Property was CLEAN..Inside and Out!!! ENTIRE staff was friendly and willing to lend a helping hand!!"

"I have been to a lot of hotels in LI but this one stands out. Staff is very pleasant and accommodating. From restaurant staff to front desk everyone was very friendly. They gave us late check out. They also do daily room service without asking which after Covid hotels have stopped doing which is another plus. Pool is on the smaller side but isn’t very busy so can accommodate. Overall great experience. Will be returning and strongly recommend. "

"Great shower! Nice and big"