Upper Matecumbe Key hotel rooms a the Benchmark

"Absolutely heavenly! Comfy beds, clean and an fun perks like a local shuttle and water taxi! Cute activities and amazing sister resort privileges! Thank you so much! "

"The people were friendly, property was well cared for. The resort was really nice. We enjoyed it all."

"Completely renovated like new very well done. This is a little gem in Islamorada. I’ll be staying here every visit now. What a find!"

"Great location, team and facilities "

"Absolutely liked everything about this hotel. From delicious breakfast options to cozy rooms with stunning views, everything exceeded my expectations. "

"This is a really great property. "

"Absolutely wonderful. Will be back!!"

"Large shower. Relaxing environment. Kayaks. Ability to use resort amenities until 4 on day of checkout. Room decorated for relaxation. "

"My experience at Baker’s Cay was outstanding from start to finish. The room was very clean, well-prepared, and super comfortable. You can really tell they pay attention to every detail. The beach area was one of my favorite spots—beautiful, peaceful, and full of fun ways to enjoy the ocean and surroundings. What truly made this trip extra special was that I was able to bring my dog with me. The resort is genuinely pet-friendly, and it made me so happy to share this vacation with him. Both restaurants at the resort were spectacular, with delicious food and excellent service. Every meal was a treat. I highly recommend this hotel if you’re looking for relaxation, great dining, and a place where your pet is just as welcome as you are. I’ll definitely be coming back!"