Ratings based on 213 Verified Reviews
4.9 Room cleanliness
4.8 Service & staff
4.8 Room comfort
4.8 Hotel condition
Expedia Verified Reviews
by A verified traveler from Fredericksburg
Posted 12 Oct 2024
A very welcoming place. The staff (front desk/breakfast attendant/housekeeping) were very attentive to our needs. The breakfast was delicious, our room meticulously cleaned. Both gentlemen that were stationed at the front desk were professional and helpful, answering our questions, suggesting places to eat and carrying our luggage during check in/ checkout. The location is on a quiet street. Our room was nicely furnished as posted on the travel site. Ww were presently pleased with all aspects our stay
by A verified traveler
Posted 1 Oct 2024
The only thing I would suggest is to offer souvenirs like the coffee mugs to be able to purchase as we have stayed there twice now and have asked to purchase but they don’t seem to want to sell them and we feel they are missing out on another revenue stream with not selling items from the hotel with their name on it. Other than that we absolutely love this place
by A verified traveler from Jacksonville
Posted 25 Sep 2024
Very nice room
We loved the his & hers hair products.
by A verified traveler
Posted 11 Sep 2024
This hotel was truly outstanding. The room was lovely, comfortable and the shower was enormous. While they claim it's a light Continental breakfast, I would say it was far more than that and the quality was excellent. I would absolutely stay here again
by A verified traveler
Posted 9 Sep 2024
Nice property but value to cost is limited
by A verified traveler
Posted 4 Sep 2024
1872 Inn was a wonderful treat. We spent 3 nights in this peaceful little hotel brimming with a western elegance not typical of this small town. It is beautifully & thoughtfully designed for ultimate comfort. The “Continental breakfast” is complete with eggs, meat, fruit & pastries. We loved our time here.
by A verified traveler
Posted 23 Aug 2024
This was an exceptional stay!! The staff, room and amenities were fantastic! The breakfast was wonderful and the comfort of our room with all the added extra like wine glasses, coffee in the room and the toiletries in the fabulous bathroom were top notch!! We will be back!!
by A verified traveler
Posted 13 Aug 2024 on Hotels
by A verified traveler
Posted 11 Aug 2024 on Hotels
by A verified traveler
Posted 9 Aug 2024
The front desk staff are all friendly and helpful! The property itself is on the outskirts of town so it's about a 10 min walk to restaurants which was fine with us. I'd recommend a 2nd floor room just so you don't hear footsteps above. Breakfast is only so-so but I really appreciated the early coffee service. Overall a great experience for West Yellowstone!
