Ratings based on 88 Verified Reviews
5.0 Room cleanliness
4.9 Room comfort
5.0 Hotel condition
Expedia Verified Reviews
by A verified traveler
Posted 18 Nov 2024
Great experience!!
Inn keepers and staff were very warm and friendly. Grounds are maintained perfectly great stay!!
Comment from Hotel Management
23 Nov 2024 by Steve & Sue Wood, Island Bay Resort, Hotel Management
Hi BrianThank you for letting us know you had a great stay with us. We hope to see you again whenever travel brings you back to the Florida Keys!
by A verified traveler
Posted 1 Nov 2024
This resort is great! Small run resort with great views. Small cottages that have a patio and a grill to use if you wanted to! The propert is beautiful and very clean! Kayaks and snorkel gear available to use when you want. I will def go back in the future
Comment from Hotel Management
23 Nov 2024 by Steve & Sue Wood, Island Bay Resort, Hotel Management
KimSo glad you enjoyed your stay and that you will definitely be returning to our little gem here in the Florida Keys!
by A verified traveler
Posted 2 Aug 2024
Outstanding property! Staff extremely attentive and professional. Grounds are meticulously kept, calm, beautiful without the crowds and busyness. Well appointed room that is comfortable with the smallest touches that made the stay unique. Will definitely be back- no reason to stay anywhere else!
Comment from Hotel Management
7 Sep 2024 by Steve & Sue Wood, Island Bay Resort, Hotel Management
JillWe are happy that you enjoyed your stay at Island Bay Resort and hope to see you back again when your travels bring you to the Florida Keys!
by A verified traveler from shawnee
Posted 22 Jul 2024
My wife and I just spent our anniversary here and highly recommended the Island Bay Resort! Sue was such an awesome and thoughtful host and helped make our stay here wonderful! Pictures and words cannot do this place justice and accurately describe what a gorgeous and peaceful property this is! You will just have to go and see for yourself!!
Comment from Hotel Management
3 Aug 2024 by Island Bay Resort, Hotel Management
LindseyThank you for your kind words. It was a pleasure meeting you and your husband and we are so glad that you stayed at our little gem in paradise as part of your anniversary celebration, and thoroughly enjoyed our property. We hope to see you again next time you are in the Florida Keys!Steve & Sue Wood
by A verified traveler from Burlington
Posted 14 Jul 2024
Tropical and beautiful. Very accommodating and peaceful.
Comment from Hotel Management
17 Jul 2024 by Island Bay Resort, Hotel Management
DarlaThank you for your review. We always love hearing that our guests enjoyed their stay. We hope to see you again if travels bring you back to the Florida Keys.
by A verified traveler
Posted 7 Jul 2024
Beautiful property, abiance is great! The paddle boards were so much fun! Property managers very friendly. We enjoyed our stay in Sunsets cottage very much.
Comment from Hotel Management
17 Jul 2024 by Island Bay Resort, Hotel Management
LucindaThank you for your sweet review. We are so happy you enjoyed your stay. We love to aid in making your stay the best experience possible. Looking forward to seeing you again if travels bring you back to the Keys.
by A verified traveler
Posted 5 Jul 2024
This place was exactly what I was looking for. Quiet and peaceful. The beach was kept very clean and the paddle boards and Kayaks were there for our use at no extra charge. The sunsets at night were spectacular. As soon as you walk out of your little cottage, you’re greeted by water. Steve and Sue couldn’t have been better hosts. They were very helpful in answering any questions I had. If you’re looking for peace of mind and tranquility, this is the place for you. I will definitely be staying here again.
Comment from Hotel Management
6 Jul 2024 by Island Bay Resort, Hotel Management
ThomasThank you for your kind review. We love it when our guests have such a great time and enjoy our little piece of paradise here at Island Bay Resort. We look forward to having you stay with us next time you are in the Florida Keys or want another R&R vacation! Steve & Sue Wood
by A verified traveler
Posted 4 Jul 2024
Steve and Sue are the best hosts!! Very personable and made our trip and nuptials memorable.
Comment from Hotel Management
6 Jul 2024 by Island Bay Resort, Hotel Management
BenWe appreciate your kindness! Steve and I enjoyed getting to know you and your sweet bride! We are so glad you came to our little gem in paradise to become a couple and share that with us! We look forward to seeing you both again and hearing all the exciting things you two have done in between. Steve & Sue Wood
by A verified traveler
Posted 30 Jun 2024 on Hotels
Comment from Hotel Management
1 Jul 2024 by Island Bay Resort, Hotel Management
EdwardThank you for taking the time to leave us a positive review. We are always grateful when our guests leave us great reviews ensuring you thoroughly enjoyed yourself! We hope to see you back again in the future if and when travel brings you back to the Florida Keys!Steve & Sue
by A verified traveler
Posted 29 Jun 2024
Staff was very friendly and accommodating. Room was clean and comfortable. Had a nice little beach and watersports equipment available.
Comment from Hotel Management
30 Jun 2024 by Island Bay Resort, Hotel Management
HaroldThank you for staying at Island Bay Resort while in the Florida Keys. We love hearing that our guests enjoyed their time with us. Hope to see you again sometime if travel brings you back this way.
