Ratings based on 1,626 Verified Reviews
5.0 Room cleanliness
4.9 Service & staff
4.9 Room comfort
4.9 Hotel condition
Expedia Verified Reviews
by A verified traveler
Posted 2 Jan 2025
We were pleased with the whole experience. High compliments to the Carlisle Inn in Sarasota.
by A verified traveler
Posted 1 Jan 2025
Property is beautiful and well maintained. It has really large rooms and hallways. I would stay there again.
Comment from Hotel Management
2 Jan 2025 by Janet Hansen, General Manager, Hotel Management
Hi Shawn,Thanks so much for your five-star review! We hope you come back again soon.
by A verified traveler
Posted 1 Jan 2025
The Carlisle Inn is an outstanding hotel. It is exceptionally clean, quiet and although they have a wonderful breakfast spread, it is a convenient walk to an excellent restaurant. The staff is friendly and extremely helpful. A five-star experience for sure!
Comment from Hotel Management
2 Jan 2025 by Janet Hansen, General Manager, Hotel Management
Hello Jean,Thank you for your wonderful review. We are So happy to hear that you enjoyed a "five-star experience!" and we hope to see you soon.
by A verified traveler
Posted 31 Dec 2024
The hotel is nice and clean, my family of 4 enjoyed the 2 night stay in the double bed room. The heated pool area was nice as well as all common areas in the hotel. There are a couple of things that could be better though - the breakfast was very basic, with rubbery scrambled eggs made out of egg powder. Another thing that we didn’t enjoy was smell in the room - it had very chemical smell of cleaning supplies. Overall, it’s a very nice hotel though.
Comment from Hotel Management
1 Jan 2025 by Janet Hansen, General Manager, Hotel Management
Hi Katerina,Thank you for your great review! We are happy to hear that you enjoyed your stay and we are truly grateful for your comments. We take our guests' feedback to heart, and we will continue to work on improving our breakfast offerings. We do not use powdered eggs in the breakfast room. We use real eggs, which are prepared by our Der Dutchman restaurant, and we hope you might give them another try if you return as our guest. Thank you again for your feedback and safe travels!
by A verified traveler
Posted 30 Dec 2024
Enjoyed my stay.
Comment from Hotel Management
31 Dec 2024 by Becky, Hotel Management
Thank you for your great review, Frances! We are so happy to hear that you enjoyed your stay with us. We hope to have you return as our guest if your travels bring you back to our area.
by A verified traveler
Posted 30 Dec 2024
This property is always outstanding. The rooms are always clean and the front desk staff are very friendly and helpful. Best breakfast!
Comment from Hotel Management
30 Dec 2024 by Becky, Hotel Management
Thank you for your "outstanding" review, Laura! We are so happy to hear that you found our front desk team to be friendly and helpful during your stay. It is our pleasure, as a team, to serve our guests. We hope to have the opportunity to welcome you back again very soon.
by A verified traveler
Posted 29 Dec 2024
This is the best hotel you can ever stay in, in your life, if you are in the area, book it the people are amazing the hotel is first class !
Comment from Hotel Management
30 Dec 2024 by Becky, Hotel Management
Thank you so much for your wonderful review, Neil! We appreciate your kind words and hope to have you return as our guest very soon!
by A verified traveler
Posted 26 Dec 2024
Comment from Hotel Management
26 Dec 2024 by Janet Hansen, General Manager, Hotel Management
Hi Justin,Thanks so much for your five-star review! We hope to see you again if you return to the Sarasota area.
by A verified traveler
Posted 25 Dec 2024
Staff promptly checked breaker when outlets were not working. Would recommend
Comment from Hotel Management
26 Dec 2024 by Janet Hansen, General Manager, Hotel Management
Hi Belinda,Thank you for your great review. We apologize that there was an issue with your guest room lighting during your stay. We are so grateful that you will recommend the Carlisle Inn Sarasota to others and we hope to see you soon!
by A verified traveler
Posted 25 Dec 2024
10/10. One of the best hotels I’ve ever stayed at. The hotel is immaculate. The rooms are huge. They do daily room cleaning, something that’s rare these days. They have free cookies every night. The hotel is next to a huge smorgasboard bakery gift store.
Comment from Hotel Management
26 Dec 2024 by Janet Hansen, General Manager, Hotel Management
Hi Urja,Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so happy to hear that the Carlisle Inn Sarasota is one of the best hotels you have ever stayed in, and we hope you come back again soon!
