Ratings based on 215 Verified Reviews
5.0 Room cleanliness
5.0 Service & staff
4.8 Room comfort
4.9 Hotel condition
Expedia Verified Reviews
by A verified traveler
Posted 3 Nov 2024
Wonderful place to stay. The home owners are lovely people. Delicious breakfasts served. Enjoy meeting fellow guests.
by A verified traveler
Posted 21 Oct 2024
I had a wonderful experience in this historic inn. The entire property was beautiful and I stayed in a unique room with antique furniture. I was served the best breakfast experience I’ve had at a U.S. Inn. It was home cooked, delicious, and so much better than continental breakfast. The host Brenda was very welcoming and accommodating.
by A verified traveler
Posted 20 Oct 2024
Felt welcomed the minute you entered the property. Very nice place to decompress for an overnight or extended period of time. I was in the area for a wedding in Eden and found this gem within 30 minutes of venue. Had a home cook meal - no reheating from packaged food - homemade jam and applesauce. Would highly recommend..
by A verified traveler
Posted 7 Oct 2024
My mother and I stayed at the Brownstone while exploring Amish country. The feeling from the moment we walked through the front door was incredible. Mark and Brenda are top notch hosts!! We stayed in the Shaker Suite which provided the feeling of being together but gave us the space of two separate bedrooms. Breakfast was absolutely delicious and Mark opened each meal with a prayer. The guests we met were repeat guests and having been to Brownstone, I can now say I understand why people come back. We can’t wait to visit again!
by A verified traveler
Posted 3 Sep 2024
by A verified traveler
Posted 30 Jun 2024
Brenda and Mark are incredibly gracious hosts and went above and beyond to make us feel welcome and cared for. Our room was very comfortable with all of the creature comforts and the icing on the cake were the delicious breakfasts- homemade, hot breakfasts including fresh ingredients from their garden! The house and the grounds are absolutely beautiful and Brenda provided excellent recommendations of local areas to visit and dining options. Thank-you Brenda and Mark for a lovely stay- we hope to visit again!
by A verified traveler
Posted 26 Jun 2024
The whole area is wonderfully peaceful. The Inn was particularly so. The hosts were lovely, caring people who have poured their hearts into making Brownstone Colonial Inn a place or restoration and rest.
by A verified traveler
Lovely Few Days
Posted 22 Jun 2024 on HotelsGreat stay.
The owners were very welcoming and helpful and the breakfast and produce was great.
We will look to return here again.
A great few days.
by A verified traveler
Posted 21 Jun 2024
5 Stars!!! My husband and I have stayed at numerous B&B's (some outside the U.S.), the Brownstone Colonial Inn tops them all. Brenda and Mark are the "Perfect" hosts. The accommodations are clean, very comfortable, and love the colonial Inn's "period" style furnishings. The gourmet breakfasts were delicious and Brenda accommodated my gluten intolerance by making the bread, as well as homemade yogurt and using produce from their garden, including peppermint for the tasty Peppermint Ice Tea. The best B & B!!!
by A verified traveler
Perfect short getaway
Posted 27 Apr 2024 on HotelsWhat a beautiful place! The outside of this historic home was perfectly manicured and the colors of the trees and flowers blooming added to the spring vibes. Brenda was so welcoming and took time when we arrived to tell us some history of the home and the area. She had local menus for dinner options and, knowing that we were there for a weekend of antiquing, had a brochure with all the local spots! Our room was charming, and my the bed was comfy. Breakfast was amazing, too, and we sat with Brenda and her husband Mark and shared stories. We had to leave before breakfast on the last day, but Brenda made sure we had coffee to go and some fresh fruit and bread for our drive home. Despite the beautiful landscape I didn’t see an outdoor lounging spot, which would’ve been nice, but there might have been one though I didn’t ask. That wouldn’t deter me from returning, though! Highly recommend this gorgeous home and its owners!!
