Ratings based on 566 Verified Reviews
4.7 Room cleanliness
4.7 Service & staff
4.3 Room comfort
4.3 Hotel condition
Expedia Verified Reviews
by A verified traveler
Posted 3 Nov 2024
Comment from Hotel Management
4 Nov 2024 by Travis, Hotel Management
Thank you for your review!
by A verified traveler
Posted 27 Oct 2024
Very quaint and cute. The hosts were kind and attentive. I had an excellent stay
Comment from Hotel Management
30 Oct 2024 by Travis, Hotel Management
Thank you for your review!
by A verified traveler from Dothan
Posted 26 Oct 2024
Beautiful view of the Waterfront and surrounding area! Thanks for making our 50th Anniversary more special!
Comment from Hotel Management
30 Oct 2024 by Travis, Hotel Management
Thank you for choosing to stay with us for your 50th anniversary!
by A verified traveler
Posted 21 Oct 2024
What a quaint, away from the Main Street noise, fabulous place to stay. This is a short walk just past the Statue of Liberty, that we walked with ease to & from Main St. The twin sisters, Rose & Caroline are friendly and welcoming & want to make sure you have everything you need to make your stay with them pleasant & enjoyable. I called in advance to make sure there were toiletries & that we're white noise sleepers & if a fan was provided. They made sure to place a box fan in our room. They even hand wrote a card welcoming & thanking us for our stay with them. Small gestures go a long way with the experience. Our room overlooked the hot tub to the property in front of this one, and kept the windows open to hear the waterfall, which was pleasant to fall a sleep to. We also had a small water view which was stunning. We chose to have the bathroom in suite & took advantage of a soak each night in the claw tub. I might recommend some bath salts or bubbles complimentary for guests, but we did find a shop in town that sold some. The bed & pillows were firm.
The breakfast was quite good, choices from bagels, Danishes, oatmeal, some sort of egg & meat dish, yogurt, and cereals. The coffee was great, and they had decaf & tea options. They served an afternoon coffee/tea time 4-5pm which was a nice treat. The playlists for both settings set a perfect ambiance. We had an amazing time visiting in October and Pine Cottage added to our wonderful experience.
Comment from Hotel Management
30 Oct 2024 by Travis, Hotel Management
Thank you so much for your thoughtful and detailed review! We're thrilled that you enjoyed the peaceful charm of Pine Cottage and that Rose and Caroline’s hospitality helped make your stay memorable. It’s great to hear the fan and personal touches enhanced your comfort and rest, and we're glad you enjoyed the tranquil sounds and view from your room. Thank you for the suggestion about bath salts—what a lovely idea! We'll certainly keep it in mind. We're delighted that the breakfast and afternoon tea met your expectations and added to the ambiance. We hope to welcome you back to Pine Cottage for another special stay in the future!
by A verified traveler
Posted 16 Oct 2024
The little touches made this property a wonderful and special choice for us. The house is well loved and cared for in its minutiae of ornate beauty, and it translates in a million different, subtle ways to you as the guest. Breakfast was plentiful and obviously homemade, the lobby and receiving room were gorgeous, decorated in period appropriate furnishings. There were books-local guides and visual marvels-and playing cards, games (and a docking station with several charger adapters). The room was small, but reasonably priced and beautifully decorated. Everything was clean, quiet and friendly-tea and cookies at 4:00pm and a lovely time to say goodbye to other guests-who all weirdly seemed like genuinely wonderful people. It was my son’s first time on the Island, and my first time in 35 years, and Pine Cottage Bed and Breakfast was an integral piece of our exceptional experience on Mackinac, we’re so grateful for the care and kindness shown by staff. I would highly recommend a stay in this glorious home. Happy vacation!
Comment from Hotel Management
18 Oct 2024 by Travis, Hotel Management
Thank you so much for your thoughtful review! We're thrilled to hear that you and your son had such a wonderful time at Pine Cottage Bed and Breakfast. It’s our pleasure to create a cozy, welcoming atmosphere, and we’re glad that the little touches—from the homemade breakfast to the afternoon tea and cookies—made your stay special. We take great pride in preserving the historic charm of the property, and we're happy to know it contributed to your exceptional Mackinac Island experience. We hope to welcome you back again soon!
by A verified traveler from Grandville
Posted 13 Oct 2024
The property is clean and maintained. The staff is attentive and courteous. The bed and breakfast is comfortable and quiet. Things to know are that unless you pay for a room with a bathroom, you will be sharing a bathroom with 3-4 other rooms. It’s worth it to have your own bathroom, in my opinion. Also, we stayed on the top floor and there is no elevator, so it’s up and down the stairs. Good for my exercise! All in all it was a pleasant experience.
Comment from Hotel Management
18 Oct 2024 by Travis, Hotel Management
Thank you for your review, we hope to see you again soon!
by A verified traveler
Posted 12 Oct 2024
Room number four had an awesome view and was very comfortable very clean. Nice bathroom nice king size bed. Breakfast was delicious. Very helpful with all of our questions about the town.
Comment from Hotel Management
13 Oct 2024 by Travis, Hotel Management
Thank you for your feedback!
by A verified traveler
Posted 12 Oct 2024
The staff was very friendly and accommodating. Breakfast was very good also. Ready to book for next year!
Comment from Hotel Management
13 Oct 2024 by Travis, Hotel Management
We look forward to your next visit!
by A verified traveler
Posted 9 Oct 2024
This was my 3rd time visiting Pine Cottage always a wonderful time. Love the history associated with the property.
Comment from Hotel Management
10 Oct 2024 by Travis, Hotel Management
Thank you for making Pine Cottage your home while on Mackinac Island!
by A verified traveler
Posted 6 Oct 2024
Comment from Hotel Management
10 Oct 2024 by Travis, Hotel Management
Thank you!
