Ratings based on 57 Verified Reviews
4.7 Room cleanliness
4.5 Service & staff
4.2 Room comfort
4.4 Hotel condition
Expedia Verified Reviews
by A verified traveler
Posted 27 Oct 2024
by A verified traveler
Posted 15 Oct 2024
We loved our stay at the Atlantic. The staff were brilliant.
Fantastic room and superb service. I would highly recomment it to anyone
Comment from Hotel Management
18 Oct 2024 by Atlantic & Bishop Manager, Hotel Management
A Traveler, thank you for your review of The Atlantic Inn, St Mary's. All feedback is greatly appreciated, and we love to hear that guests have enjoyed their visit. We’re looking forward to welcoming you back soon. Thank you, and have a fantastic day!
by A verified traveler
Posted 7 Aug 2024
Comment from Hotel Management
18 Sep 2024 by Atlantic & Bishop Manager, Hotel Management
Hi A Traveler, Thanks for taking the time to leave a review for your recent visit to The Atlantic Inn, St Mary's. We always strive to deliver a great experience for our guests and look forward to welcoming you back soon. Best wishes, The Atlantic Inn, St Mary's General Manager
by A verified traveler
Posted 16 Jul 2024
I throughly enjoyed my stay at The Atlantic.
The staff were all friendly and very helpful. The room was spacious and clean. The sheets were crisp and of good quality and the towels were soft and well laundered. The Elemis toiletries were a nice touch as was the fan provided in the room. The only issue with my room (1) was the loo seat was loose. I mention it here not to complain but to highlight so it can be addressed.
The continental breakfast left a little to be desired but I may have been late as the room was emptying. However the cooked breakfast was very good with the bacon being cooked to perfection. None of that awful, anaemic looking boiled stuff.
Dinner was enjoyable with a great seat and good food. My only criticism would be the waitress didn’t present the wine. I was left to open and pour it myself. I know I am being punctilious but there are certain elements of service which can’t be done away with. She was young and perhaps on her first season. What she lacked in etiquette she made up for in promptness and attentiveness so I can’t hold it against her.
The location and views afforded are all to be desired. I would recommend anyone to stay at The Atlantic.
Comment from Hotel Management
12 Sep 2024 by Atlantic & Bishop Manager , Hotel Management
Hi Samuel, Thanks for taking the time to leave a review for your recent visit to The Atlantic Inn, St Mary's. We always strive to deliver a great experience for our guests and look forward to welcoming you back soon. Best wishes, The Atlantic Inn, St Mary's General Manager
by A verified traveler
Lovely pub, comfy rooms and great service!
Posted 28 Jun 2024 on HotelsComfortable room with modern bathroom and lovely view over the harbour. Staff were all really friendly and helpful and the breakfast was fab. Sitting on the terrace with a drink in the evening looking out over the harbour was fantastic, thank you!
by A verified traveler
Posted 9 Jun 2024 on Hotels
by A verified traveler
Posted 25 Apr 2024
Room as advertised. Over looking harbour. Very comfortable. Friendly helpful staff. Quiz night was abit loud but it was all over by 11 pm. Lovely breakfast
by A verified traveler
Posted 30 Oct 2023
Comment from Hotel Management
27 Nov 2023 by Atlantic & Bishop Manager, Hotel Management
Hi Matt, Thanks for taking the time to leave a review for your recent visit to The Atlantic Inn, St Mary's. We always strive to deliver a great experience for our guests and look forward to welcoming you back soon.
by A verified traveler
Posted 22 Sep 2023 on Hotels
Lovely staff comfortable rooms and delicious breakfasts
by A verified traveler
Posted 22 Sep 2023 on Hotels
