Ratings based on 22 Verified Reviews
4.9 Room cleanliness
4.9 Service & staff
4.7 Room comfort
4.7 Hotel condition
Expedia Verified Reviews
by A verified traveler
Posted 28 Jun 2024
by A verified traveler
Posted 21 Aug 2023
This was a great place to stay with old word charm. If you are looking for a quiet getaway with a beautiful view of the ocean this is it. The breakfast that we had were much better that what you could get in town. My wife and I can't wait to go back.
by A verified traveler
Posted 3 Aug 2023 on Hotels
by A verified traveler
Posted 9 Jul 2023
by A verified traveler
Posted 7 May 2023
We booked this property to celebrate our 17th anniversary for an 1 night night getaway. Upon check in we were greeted with the most delicious homemade cupcakes with our name on it and warmly welcomed by Clay, the property host. We parked right in front, and walked to various bars and restaurants so it was so convenient and vibrant and didn’t have to worry about driving. On the way back we saw the most amazing moonset on the water (the property is basically on the water separated by a street), there’s a dock you can walk out to. Clay cooked us the best farm to table breakfast, it was so delicious, he really takes the time and effort to make everything perfect. We will definitely stay here again!
Comment from Hotel Management
10 May 2023 by Clay, Hotel Management
Thank you for your kind words! We hope to see you again soon.
by A verified traveler
Posted 13 Mar 2023
Clay was the perfect host. Friendly and very helpful. And an amazing baker! Our breakfast was outstanding. Our room was very cozy and had a great view. We really enjoyed our stay.
Comment from Hotel Management
10 May 2023 by Clay, Hotel Management
It was great hosting you for your stay. Now that the weather is warmer, we hope you'll consider coming again soon!
by A verified traveler from Centennial
Posted 28 Feb 2023
Wonderful old property across street from the water. Breakfast was amazing. However, due to the age of the property, there are certain aspects that are acceptable but not optimal. However the property scores a 10 on quaint.
by A verified traveler
The best B&B we have ever stayed at.
Posted 11 Sep 2022 on Hotelsby A verified traveler
Posted 9 Jan 2022
Loved our stay at Stirling House. Room very clean and comfortable. Beautiful views of waterfront. Breakfast was Delicious! Great place to stay if enjoying the North Fork Wineries!!
by A verified traveler from Smithtown
Posted 5 Dec 2021
