Ratings based on 276 Verified Reviews
4.7 Room cleanliness
4.5 Service & staff
4.4 Room comfort
4.4 Hotel condition
Expedia Verified Reviews
by A verified traveler
Posted 22 Dec 2024
Unique, charming. Delicious dinner.
Comment from Hotel Management
31 Dec 2024 by Captain Whidbey Team, Hotel Management
Thank you, Lisa!
by A verified traveler
Posted 11 Dec 2024
Comment from Hotel Management
19 Dec 2024 by CW Team, Hotel Management
Thank you, Daisy! We are glad you had a great stay!
by A verified traveler
Posted 27 Nov 2024
It was beautiful and relaxing. Food was excellent
Comment from Hotel Management
30 Nov 2024 by CW Team, Hotel Management
Thank you, Kelley! We are glad you had a great time, and enjoyed dining with us as well. We hope to have you back soon, cheers!
by A verified traveler
Posted 6 Nov 2024
Comment from Hotel Management
7 Nov 2024 by Front Desk Team, Hotel Management
Thank you for the feedback! If you would like to give us further insight on your stay, we would invite you to reach out to our team so we know how we can go from ok to great!
by A verified traveler
Posted 2 Nov 2024
Amazing Property. Great food and cocktails.
Comment from Hotel Management
7 Nov 2024 by Front Desk Team, Hotel Management
Thank you Kelly! We are glad you had a great time staying with us and in our restaurant! We hope to have you back soon.
by A verified traveler
Posted 10 Oct 2024
was a nice place to get away, historic property in a beautiful setting
Comment from Hotel Management
10 Oct 2024 by Captain Whidbey Team, Hotel Management
Hi Jon,Thank you so much for staying with us and taking time to leave us a review! We hope to see you again. Cheers,
by A verified traveler
Posted 6 Oct 2024
Overall, a unique experience and would do it again on a special occasion! But for the cost, especially during the low season, there isn't a lot to do. The sauna is for only a couple of people at a time, and the restaurant and cocktails were too pricey to eat there for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. But the property itself is beautiful and so serene. We really enjoyed the fire pits in the evening as well.
Comment from Hotel Management
8 Oct 2024 by Front Desk Team, Hotel Management
Thank you, Genesse! We are glad you enjoyed your stay, and appreciate the thoughtful feedback about activities in the off season. Thank you again, we hope to have you back!
by A verified traveler
Posted 14 Sep 2024
A quiet beautiful setting with lots of areas to sit & take in the fresh air & views
Comment from Hotel Management
16 Sep 2024 by Captain Whidbey Team, Hotel Management
Hello Martha! Thank you for your kind words, we are glad you enjoyed your stay with us. We hope you have a wonderful day, and will come visit again soon!
by A verified traveler
Posted 4 Sep 2024
Lovely setting complemented with perfect weather (amazing when it happens). Check in/out was painless
Comment from Hotel Management
9 Sep 2024 by Captain Whidbey Team, Hotel Management
Thank you, Daniel! We are glad your stay and weather were prefect! We hope to have you back. Cheers!
by A verified traveler
Posted 23 Aug 2024 on Hotels
The hotel is very rustic and like being in a log cabin. Dining conveniently located on the premises. The restaurant is very good. Staff are very pleasant and helpful. The bed was very comfortable. The room was pretty basic. My main reason for not giving 5 star was that you can hear the other guests next door. Fortunately, they quieted down around 11.
Comment from Hotel Management
25 Aug 2024 by Captain Whidbey Team, Hotel Management
Thank you, Arthur! We are glad you enjoyed your stay, and that our staff was kind and helpful! We strive to provide great service to our guests. We do offer other rooms that are a little more private, such as our Cabins and Lagoon rooms. Hopefully you can come stay again and experience different room types! Thank you again, we hope you have a great day. Cheers!
