Ratings based on 352 Verified Reviews
4.4 Room cleanliness
4.3 Service & staff
4.2 Room comfort
4.0 Hotel condition
Expedia Verified Reviews
by A verified traveler
Posted 31 Dec 2024
We stayed in the Southern Quarters over Christmas. The cottage had heat but our room never warmed up above 57 degrees. The staff did provide a space heater that we put in the bathroom. The cottage had a small kitchen with a coffee maker, microwave, and refrigerator.
Overall we had a very pleasant time in Cape May. Yes the room was cold but very comfortable. It made for a a memorable Christmas.
by A verified traveler
Posted 30 Dec 2024
Our stay was very nice, everything was exactly what we wanted. Our only complaint is that since there is a bar attached to the property, it got a bit noisy at night. Would stay again, though!
by A verified traveler
Posted 25 Dec 2024
Was an amazing experience only downside was we couldn’t stay longer. Easy check in and check out. Will be back!
by A verified traveler
Posted 21 Dec 2024
Decent
by A verified traveler
Posted 21 Dec 2024
Everything everywhere was a winter wonderland 🎄I definitely will be returning and be staying at the Chalfonte.
by A verified traveler
Posted 17 Dec 2024
Beautiful grounds..lots of cool cubby hole rooms on the main floor - tons of gorgeous antiques throughout. Great History.
by A verified traveler
Posted 15 Dec 2024
I can't speak for warmer weather, but we stayed in December. The main hotel was closed, which we were not told when booking. We were looking for the Christmas experience. There was no contact with any hotel staff. We stayed in what they called the Southern Quarters, a separate building that housed 6 rooms. Even though the room had heat it was very cold. We were very cold all night.
The floors were like ice. The bathroom was freezing! I don't think there was any heat in there. I would not recommend staying here in the cold weather.
by A verified traveler
Posted 14 Dec 2024
by A verified traveler from Somers
Posted 12 Dec 2024
Although only part of the hotel is opened this time of year, I enjoyed this lovely clean , quiet property perfect for my visit to Cape May.I look forward to a return stay when this charming hotel is fully opened with it's restaurant and rocking chair porch ..a step back in time...
by A verified traveler
Posted 10 Dec 2024
I loved the welcome handwritten envelope—loved everything. I am very appreciative and honored to have had these 2 nights at this most historical location.
