Ratings based on 60 Verified Reviews
4.8 Room cleanliness
4.8 Service & staff
4.9 Room comfort
4.8 Hotel condition
Expedia Verified Reviews
by A verified traveler from New Berlin
Posted 6 Oct 2024
Perfect location for our visit
by A verified traveler
Posted 20 Sep 2024
Loved staying at the Lodge. Beautiful home and a great location to shops and restaurants. Took out the paddle boards and enjoyed a relaxing time sitting in the sun in the water front property. Highly recommend. Hosts are great and very helpful.
by A verified traveler
Posted 17 Sep 2024
This is one amazing hotel . The staff is top shelf . The property is in a great location . The shops in the town have quantity shops and great restaurants. I’ll be back soon
by A verified traveler
Posted 10 Sep 2024
Monte and Kelly are wonderful owners and the inn feels like you are staying at home. I would definitely go back again!
by A verified traveler
Posted 3 Sep 2024
We loved everything about our too short stay! Kelly and Monte were lovely, gracious hosts! Our room was clean and beautiful and our common area was lovely. The Jacuzzi was amazing, overlooking the bay. Will definitely return for another, longer, getaway.
Diana and Bill Beck
by A verified traveler
Posted 12 Aug 2024
Do not book this place. They double booked their property even after confirming the day before about our arrival. We had paid and booked for this place a year in advance. They were not helpful, unresponsive, and unapologetic after we arrived, as they do not meet you at the property you can only get a hold of them via phone/text. Expedia tried for days to get a hold of them for a refund on our behalf. We eventually found a place to stay in the area and never saw anyone at this property. I would not risk booking here, as the options are limited in the area, which make things difficult in scenarios like this.
by A verified traveler from Malverne
Posted 10 Aug 2024
Kelly was a great host. Very cute lodge style inn on the bay on the main strip of town. Beautifully decorated with lots of antiques and cool stuff throughout the house. Continental breakfast is left out for you on main floor in the kitchen. Bagels, muffins , pastries etc. there is a fridge on each floor that’s kinda family style. Take what you want, leave what you have extra of. One of the strange things was our private bath was across the hall of the game room/ lounge are so we had to be careful when streaking but it worked out fine. There are only about a half dozen rooms and people go out exploring most of the day so you pretty much have the whole place to yourself. Look forward to staying there again soon. Thanks again.
by A verified traveler
Posted 8 Aug 2024
by A verified traveler
Perfect in every way
Posted 16 Jul 2024 on HotelsAmazing place with so many more perks than expected. It’s in the heart of town, in beautiful condition, felt so private even with other guests and had so many unexpected amenities. We would definitely stay here again! The breakfast spread was so thoughtful and the water toys were perfect. SUPs, kayaks, peddle boats, lily pad, etc.
Two huge balconies and a yard at the waters edge with dock. Everything we could have wanted!
Comment from Hotel Management
16 Jul 2024 by Kelly, Hotel Management
Thank you Tabitha for your beautiful review! We enjoyed having you and hope to see you again! Kelly, Monte and Marc.
by A verified traveler
Posted 15 Jul 2024
Great place to stay. Beautiful
Comment from Hotel Management
16 Jul 2024 by Kelly, Hotel Management
Thank you for staying with us! We are happy you enjoyed your stay!
