Ratings based on 27 Verified Reviews

4.9 out of 5
100% of guests recommend
4.9 Room cleanliness
4.8 Service & staff
4.9 Room comfort
4.7 Hotel condition
Expedia Verified Reviews
5 out of 5
by A verified traveler

Posted 8 Jan 2024
We spent a long weekend here and it was breathtaking! The service is outstanding and the food was great. I highly recommend the BOMC for a romantic getaway!
5 out of 5
by A verified traveler

Posted 29 Apr 2023
Great views, secluded 5 star retreat
5 out of 5
by A verified traveler

A beautiful place- should be a secret!!

Posted 11 Mar 2023 on Hotels
Delightful spot for a spell of “down” time. From the greeting at the dock to the farewells the staff were engaging and very friendly. Clean and very comfortable accommodation.Food delicious if slow service at times. Gin and wine advice from 18 yr old gap year students was amusing!Boating on the water, swimming and walking provided exercise and the dolphins, seals, stingrays and birds also greeted us!! The lookout walk was our greatest challenge- very steep but views over 360 degrees were stunning. Water taxi transfer across the Sound was also spectacular. Thank you
4 out of 5
by A verified traveler from Pukekohe

Posted 5 Jan 2023
As soon as you arrive at BOMC you are greeted by a staff member and shown around. Our room was absolutely stunning, amazing views, comfy bed and pillows. Once we heard of the Peanut Slab challenge of course we can to do it. I loved the pool and hot tub. The staff were all friendly and the turn down service is definitely the best I’ve come across. Loved there was a free laundry service. The ONLY thing that we thought let it down was the food. Our meals were very average not what you would expect at a 5 star lodge.
4 out of 5
by A verified traveler

Not sure about 5 star

Posted 21 Jan 2020 on Hotels
Unique location accessible only by water taxi so getting charged an extra $200 for the privilege of getting to and from the hotel mildly amusing or if you’re remotely budget constrained a bit of a cheek. However service at the bight cafe venue was truly dreadful for a purportedly 5 star hotel. Being told to get your own sauce from the bottle rack wasn’t great (waitress could just as easily have brought it over rather than pointing to their location in a pretty aggressive manner) but the ‘manager’ of the day (English and red headed) seemed so much more interested in serving 2 young ladies their second bottle of champagne than a couple of hotel residents it felt plain rude. Check out was a farce with the duty manager attempting to charge for dinner and breakfast meals when we had booked half board And then telling us we didn’t understand before finally (bit of an argument ensued) taking the additional charges off the bill. If you do go there make sure the hotel includes dinner bed and breakfast (you are a captive audience so may as well)
Comment from Hotel Management
21 Jan 2020 by Graeme & Kim Smith, Hotel Management
Disappointing feedback in some respects Bob and contrary to your comments on departure. Not sure why you would consider it cheeky to charge for water taxis. Cougarline is a separate business to the Bay of Many Coves and they are not in the habit of offering free water taxi transfers to the Resort - just for kicks? Would you consider it 'cheeky' if a rental car company charged you car hire costs to drive to a hotel in Queenstown? I do accept your feedback on the Bight Cafe. It is a nemesis which is set to close fopr good at the end of this season and will be replaced with a "guest lounge" . Unfortunately over the years - the cafe has taken away the focus from the resort and for exactly the reasons you noted - we have decided to re-purpose this space and replace it with a guest lounge and bar area and will also re-locate our reception to this space also. Finally - to clarify your checkout. Your booking from Expedia was in fact NOT dinner, bed and breakfast as you had believed, but in fact what you paid for was Bed and Breakfast - with dinner to be charged separately to your account. Rianne rightly checked you out so as not to cause a scene and waited for us to return from a day off to follow up. What you considered a farce was actually Rianne trying to make sense of your understanding of your booking - which was at odds with what you actually paid for. As a result - there remains a balance of $460.00 against your account which Kim and I have taken the decision to write off as we truly believe that you thought that this was part of your package - when in fact it wasn't. Bob - we enjoyed having you and your wife stay, but just needed to set the story straight as I think your comments (with the exception of the cafe, which we completely accept) were a little harsh and unwarranted.
5 out of 5
by A verified traveler

We'll be back!

Posted 20 Jan 2020 on Hotels
Amazing and unique location on the north end of the south island or NZ. Fabulous welcoming, wonderful apartment with amazing views. Great food. Great Service.
Comment from Hotel Management
21 Jan 2020 by Graeme & Kim Smith, Hotel Management
Thank you so much for your feedback. We are proud of this property and feedback like this makes it all worthwhile. Safe onward travels in New Zealand.
5 out of 5
by A verified traveler

This traveler left a rating score only Posted 22 Aug 2019 on Hotels
5 out of 5
by A verified traveler

This traveler left a rating score only Posted 10 Aug 2019 on Hotels
5 out of 5
by Amanda

Paradise

Posted 19 Mar 2017 on Hotels
We had the most wonderful 3 days away in paradise - the staff were fantastic and friendly and went out of their way to make sure our stay was perfect. The food is exceptional with a highly skilled team of chefs who were happy to catering to individual dietary requirements. And thanks to Natalie and Elaine for their help to make our special day so wonderful too!
5 out of 5
by A verified traveler

Posted 18 Mar 2016 on Hotels
Hot tub didn't work and food was quite expensive otherwise great